A short explainer on how El Niño works [video] (youtube.com)
breakyerself 5 hours ago
9rx 4 hours ago
Risk is subjective, so this doesn't mean much without quantifying what you feel is risky to you. Moreover, of all the risks we have heard expressed in the population, there is no unary growth value. There is a change in distribution, and some risks have grown, but some risks have also shrunk. If you are relying on the reader to bring their own idea of what the risks are, this is almost certainly going to be false.
I expect you say this with good intentions, trying to instil fear in the reader to convince them that climate change is something to pay attention to. But this kind of "absolute truth" that doesn't hold up to scrutiny is what actually turns people off paying attention to something that justifiably does warrant attention. Let's do better.
esalman 3 hours ago
9rx 3 hours ago
esalman 2 hours ago
nsoam 3 hours ago
Sharlin 3 hours ago
tingletech 3 hours ago
9rx 3 hours ago
infinite_spin 3 hours ago
9rx 2 hours ago
infinite_spin 2 hours ago
breakyerself 3 hours ago
Our infrastructure and agriculture are designed around a climate regime that is increasingly becoming a thing of the past. I think your attitude about this shit is nonsensical
EdwardDiego 2 hours ago
And that's the thing - our climate is a massively complex system of interacting systems, and now we've put more energy into it, and it'll show up in the variability.
Loquebantur 3 hours ago
Instead of acknowledging the scientific facts and the ethical implications thereof, they engage in "catch me if you can"-tactics.
They let themselves be willfully utilized as a shield of ignorance against the financial restitution they owe. Not to speak of the implied loss of influence in the world economy after fossil fuels are phased out.
echelon 3 hours ago
Telling them this will make them vote even stronger in the other way. Especially if you call them stupid, selfish, etc.
You have to show them how it impacts eg. the cost of insurance for coastal properties. But even so, this is hard to convey. The people voting aren't feeling it and are told by coastal elites what to care about - changing their opinion in the opposite direction.
Some countries are even going to benefit tremendously from warming, eg. Russia gets more arable land and access to the North Sea, which is fantastic for trade, energy, and defense.
Loquebantur 2 hours ago
Telling people the truth evokes all kinds of weird reactions, that doesn't mean you shouldn't do it.
The preservation of our shared prerequisite for our continued existence isn't accurately captured by financial metrics. Pretending it was is a major error.
You start with protecting "people" (you are included?) against supposed accusations of stupidity, only to then go on and paint them (and yourself) as stupid and unable to judge connections and consequences correctly. And even stoop to pointing at whataboutisms of imaginary upsides.
criddell 2 hours ago
Maybe it does mean that. If you want people to listen you need to avoid having them immediately tune you out.
Loquebantur 2 hours ago
When your child acts in such a way (imagine it trying to kill its pet, which it was tasked with sustaining), what do you do? Entertain its fantasies and accommodate its wishes?
The point here is, you enable people to act in such childish ways by inventing justifications for their behavior. Your own prior behavior might well be the cause of their actions in the first place.
jibalt 32 minutes ago
criddell 29 minutes ago
The oil companies pushed bullshit but they knew how to deliver the message and they were effective. People who want to reduce CO2 emissions have not been effective delivering their message yet they keep trying the same thing over-and-over again.
cmrdporcupine 3 hours ago
Sorry, great grand-children. Pipelines gotta pump.
ianjbutler 2 hours ago
This is arguably the correct thing, even if you believe the situation is urgent, if you also believe that other things are more urgent. Suppose you think that fixing declining education or economies is absolutely prerequisite, and that until people are smarter or more comfortable or both, even discussing the climate too often weakens your chances of building effective coalitions.
Personally, I go back and forth when I weigh this sort of thing, I'm really not sure. We probably need to at least consider that this is a consistent/coherent perspective. Of course, it's not a invitation to make things worse as fast as possible with drill-baby-drill.. but an acknowledgement that there are many other ways to make things worse, such as pissing people off. Aggravating corporations is fine, but for people who are not ready to hear about this, we need real consideration and a real offer. However inconsistently, we have tried forcing an agenda they need to comply with already, so now let's try something else
jibalt 28 minutes ago
taneq 9 minutes ago
hax0ron3 35 minutes ago
Despite this, I don't have the time or energy to really care much about climate change. I have more immediate problems. I have bills to pay. I barely think about climate change at all. Maybe it would be different if I had children, but I'm not sure. Children make people care more about the non-immediate future, but they also take time and energy. So it's hard to say.
I'm probably pretty representative of the average person in this regard.
jibalt 29 minutes ago
bko 2 hours ago
Even when adjusting for trade, it is down considerably over the last 20 years. Mainly due to dematerialization, basically a free market economy doing more with less (e.g. efficient packaging uses less materials and is cheaper).
US and the Western world can continue reducing carbon emissions and it won't make a bit of difference.
Try spending 5 minutes on google before you spout uniformed opinions
Noaidi 2 hours ago
How much of China's CO2 is a result of the products Americans buy that were manufactured in China?
If we look at CO2 as a result of consumption it would tell a truer story.
hollerith an hour ago
There are manufacturing processes that use a lot of energy, and the US does a lot of that (maybe more than China) because it has low energy costs.
belorn 29 minutes ago
On the flip side, we should not take away agency from those who choose to favor increased export industry over increased emissions. That is an active choice. Same if they allow poor employment safety or child labor. The importer of goods has some moral responsibility to buy from someone else (even if its more expensive), but the absolute majority of responsibility is on the country that actively allow such practices. Emission numbers can't be white washed by claiming that it goes to exports, as if being paid to do it means zero responsibility (a very strange notion to begin with).
suprjami 2 hours ago
Things might have improved from 20 years ago but the more recent governmental trend is not positive.
willmadden an hour ago
These people are not arguing in good faith.
xedrac an hour ago
jibalt 35 minutes ago
defrost 32 minutes ago
It'd better to avoid country V country pissing contests and focus on global efforts. In a real sense the cost of going solar, wind, renewable powered is Chinese emissions .. for now.
defrost 35 minutes ago
See HN guidelines, and perhaps steelman their claim.
By "outsize responsibility" they likely refer to the fact that still today the US as a country has been the source of the largest per country contribution to AGW gases (burnt fossil fuels).
They might also refer to 1970s US capitalists (eg: Koch brothers) doubling down hard on climate denial after the papers of 1967 and actively funding think tanks to push civic development towards roads, away from public transport, and make bigger cars sexy.
To this day the cumulative total of fossil gases uplifted by the US still exceeds that of China - despite the smaller population of the USS.
rustcleaner 2 hours ago
lotsofpulp 2 hours ago
Interesting way to frame the constraints of reality.
dd8601fn 2 hours ago
It’s not far from what I’ve always thought. We simply will not solve these problems with broad self-denial. It’s an absurd notion, even if the monastic sheen of it sounds nice.
Loquebantur 2 hours ago
Reality doesn't allow for any such thing and wishing for it doesn't make it so.
Consequently, ignoring that reality will see you running into a wall head-on. With wildly devastating consequences: El Niño is just one immediate symptom, look at the AMOC. It collapsing will see about 70% or more of Earth's population wiped out. Along with the corresponding capacity for crop growth.
What you need to do is actually preventing foreseeable calamities, not complaining about people pointing you at them.
hax0ron3 an hour ago
People in communism, or nearly any other socioeconomic system, also want more housing, transport, food, energy, and children.
Reality includes public opinion, which even authoritarian systems have to account for to some extent. So even if the reality is that climate change will be so devastating that it needs to be addressed by any means necessary (I don't know if that is the reality, but let's say for the sake of argument that it is), that necessity has to be sold to people somehow.
And it's difficult to convince people to accept impoverishment if the truly major negative consequences of not acting on climate change are ones that will not happen for decades, as seems to be the case at least in temperate regions. I know very little about AMOC, but it seems the science about AMOC collapse timelines is not settled enough to convince the average person that something must be done immediately.
To get public buy-in in such a situation, it may be more advantageous to figure out how to be able to sell the necessary changes in a way that is not accompanied by impoverishment. That or ignore public buy-in, but then one still has to figure out how to do that. Voters punish economic decline. And I doubt that there is a realistic path to replacing Western democracy with an authoritarian system that has climate change as a top priority, at least in the near future.
jibalt 37 minutes ago
d4mi3n 9 minutes ago
criddell 2 hours ago
Those of us who want to see CO2 reductions need to find solutions that don’t lead to inflation in the short term. It’s probably going to be a technological rather than policy solution.
noosphr an hour ago
The current one seems to be doing the same as the old one.
Climate is filled with non linearities and drawing straight lines from the past is a fools errant.
Least we forget the Sahara only turned into a desert when it got less sunshine.
jibalt 22 minutes ago
Climate scientists disagree.
> The last El Nino caused an extremely wet summer in Australia despite a century of data pointing in the opposite direction.
No, that occurrence is not inconsistent with the data.
> Climate is filled with non linearities and drawing straight lines from the past is a fools errant.
The word is "errand" and this is absurd ... climate is an average over weather, we can plot a trend line, and that line has an upward slope.
stingraycharles 8 minutes ago
rene_d 5 hours ago
simpsond 4 hours ago
_ache_ 2 hours ago
France isn't very much affected, so it's not focused on any country.
guilhermeasper 3 hours ago
romanovcode 4 hours ago
heikkilevanto 3 hours ago
darkwater 3 hours ago
jeffbee 5 hours ago
slicktux 4 hours ago
vibebingo 3 hours ago