Octopuses have a much more distributed system than mammals, suggesting a quite different approach is possible.
'Birdbrain' Is a Misnomer. Crows Make Decisions Faster Than We Can (nytimes.com)
Animats 5 hours ago
greymalik 4 hours ago
Computer0 4 hours ago
olivermuty 4 hours ago
Tiger shrimp are also in the picture eventually.
shostack 4 hours ago
olivermuty 2 hours ago
Vetch 2 hours ago
avadodin an hour ago
shostack 4 hours ago
literalAardvark 21 minutes ago
And I've read a lot.
larodi 4 hours ago
glenstein 3 hours ago
I have to imagine that corvids and mammals had a common ancestor with more working brain structure. Though maybe you can make the case that "intelligence" showing up later on isn't the same thing as simply having a brain.
But it's much more impressive to me that there's convergent evolution from brainless to brain-having, than from brains to intelligent brains. Don't get me wrong, it's still awesome but doesn't feel like an out of nowhere path for natural selection to take.
SoftTalker 2 hours ago
tsimionescu 2 hours ago
Intelligence actually exists at all levels of life, and brains are just an apex of achievement, just like eyes are an apex achievement of light-sensing mechanisms that similarly exist all around the tree of life.
stevenwoo 2 hours ago
NoMoreNicksLeft 2 hours ago
So it doesn't really matter that technically you are correct.
glenstein 2 hours ago
I would venture a guess that nearly all animals will turn out "intelligent" if all we really mean is they things like complex immune responses to disease, or complex coordination needed to grow an embryo. Those matter and raise profound questions about how incredible natural selection can be, but I would wait for an actual sin of commission before treating any commentary on animal intelligence like it neglects to appreciate sophisticated behavior of cells.
Sharlin 3 hours ago
Vetch 2 hours ago
Among parrots, everyone knows African Greys but cockatoos are also highly intelligent, with goffin's cockatoos the standouts in terms of cleverness.
anjel 2 hours ago
remix2000 2 hours ago
kulahan an hour ago
Edit but as an aside, we don't even really know what intelligence is, if you ask me. We have an idea, but trying to quantify it or measure it falls short seemingly every time.
tosapple 39 minutes ago
i guess i misremembered,
https://www.sciencealert.com/scientists-collected-deep-sea-r...
they oxidized in the lab, maybe they're not shiny or curious enough of an object to be collected?
what animals perform collection?
ElProlactin 34 minutes ago
Don't worry. We're getting there.
Dylan16807 11 minutes ago
singingfish 2 hours ago
I wish I understood enough of the appropriate level of neuroscience to get a bit of an understanding of the similarities and differences between bird and other brains.
chrisvls 2 hours ago
Turkeys are also legendary. Like the farmer brings three of them out, chops the head of the first one off. The other two are still standing there. “Wow! Look what happened to Charley! I wonder what this line is for.”
“Birdbrain” may be wrong for corvids but too complimentary to turkeys.
jyounker an hour ago
singingfish an hour ago
ChrisMarshallNY an hour ago
0xBA5ED 6 hours ago
tapland 6 hours ago
dlcarrier 5 hours ago
davrosthedalek 5 hours ago
toast0 4 hours ago
echelon 5 hours ago
The term implies something that feels like "dodo" or imbecile.
Corvids and parrots and raptors are remarkably smart, yet not every bird species is. Some are incredibly stupid.
There's also the anecdote (maybe just in the American South?) of a chicken running around with its head cut off.
Also think of the "Always Sunny" meme where they call Dee a "bird" all the time [1]. It's meant to mean stupid, amongst other things.
GauntletWizard 5 hours ago
skupig 4 hours ago
dieselgate 4 hours ago
al_borland 4 hours ago
The Always Sunny thing is more about her looks. When they call her dumb, they tend to just call her dumb/stupid/etc.
I would imagine the Dodo is a big reason for the birdbrain insult meaning dumb. Since Dodo itself can be used to mean dumb, and since they weren't afraid of humans they were easy targets and hunted to extinction. That may say more about humans than the Dodo.
pjmlp 4 hours ago
You will find similar middle age tales.
emmelaich 3 hours ago
cyberax 3 hours ago
Raptors are pretty stupid. They don't _need_ to be smart. They're solitary and they are typically apex predators.
I have a great view out of my window, and I have a family of crows living nearby. They cooperated to drive out owls and eagles that were nesting in a nearby park. Right now it's raining with pretty strong gusty winds and the crows are flying outside, doing pretty crazy aerobatics. They are clearly having a lot of fun!
I have never seen pigeons or seagulls do that.
SoftTalker 2 hours ago
cyberax 2 hours ago
But crows were not just soaring, they were diving, doing loop-de-loops, chasing each other. Something like this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FIWEFaVeWfw
It's really hard to take a good video of that.
teiferer 2 hours ago
That's from an anthropomorphized angle though? In their evolutionary niche, their level of expressed intelligence seems to be spot on, otherwise they'd have evolved or been outcompeted long ago.
In fact, some of those species that you might consider "incredibly stupid" may have existed long before humans and might easily outlive us if we follow some not-very-unlikely paths that we have opened up with technology and (lack of) social maturity. Who is "incredibly stupid" then?
jyounker an hour ago
t-3 2 hours ago
jyounker an hour ago
t-3 5 minutes ago
deadnomore 4 hours ago
glenstein 4 hours ago
Some birds have impressive specializations, and corvids clearly punch above their brain mass weight due to impressive efficiencies with their brain architecture, but I think the framing of the article is more wrong than right to frame it around speedy information processing of particular problems.
rdiddly 3 hours ago
teiferer 2 hours ago
silverFork 3 hours ago
WalterBright 4 hours ago
For example, learning to play a piano is training the spine, not the brain. Because the feedback loop with the spine is shorter.
It's the same with dancing. One is trained to not look at one's feet, because the feedback loop is too slow.
alexgoodhart 4 hours ago
And playing a musical instrument like piano depends heavily on interactive processes throughout the brain and PNS
TeMPOraL 3 hours ago
What do you dance with, then, and why there are step diagrams (with lines and little shoe prints) for classical dances?
alexgoodhart 3 hours ago
Re: the gotcha question, because these are simplified diagrams for teaching beginners or communicating genre-informed choreographies in shorthand. Even then, nobody achieve's any dancing simply by moving their feet as the diagram depicts (and they couldn't possible do so without the rest of their body). Part of the reason for their success is that people are already familiar with dances and combine the diagram's directions with the understanding that they must achieve it with a full body vocabulary.
teiferer 2 hours ago
It may train the spine too but good luck trying to play the piano without a brain. More concretely, your eyes read the notes you like to play, your ears provide the feedback loop whether you are playing the right thing (and dynamics and interplay with other musicians in an ensemble), and you need things like planning ahead, sense of form, etc. Twiching fingers from some spine impulse is just part of playing the piano. (Besides, the latency between brain and finger muscels is insubstantial w.r.t. the time scales you need for general music playing, beyond certain nuances.)
WalterBright 39 minutes ago
I think you missed the point.
The brain is the general, the spine is the sergeant.
singingfish 2 hours ago
The flying lifestyle creates size constraints, and nerve conduciton distances will be shorter and that will make some sort of difference.
But dusting off some very rusty student memories, we're not really working in real time - some latencies bottom out a 5ms, but 30-100ms is more common - if I am recalling correctly.
jyounker an hour ago
bob1029 an hour ago
WalterBright an hour ago
I saw an article about it years ago.
lukan 15 minutes ago
warrenski 3 hours ago
[1] https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/25938481-the-genius-of-b...
randomImmigrant 5 hours ago
Their body clocks are also significantly more sophisticated and decentralized than ours.
And in the end, the physical intelligence of flight itself demands a brain that's gotta be incredibly spatially and temporally aware.
I wish our brains had some of the skills and efficiencies of birds.
gumby 5 hours ago
You can harness your somatic infrastructure to gain some senses, like magnetic field sensitivity. Some people implant small permanent magnets in a fingertip to sense magnetic field, and claim it makes the world more interesting.
Unfortunately such an implant is not itself permanent (you'd want to coat it with something safe that doesn't trigger the immune system like gold or PTFE). Also though you want to be careful around other magnets I imagine!
But you could probably wear a magnetic sensor that used something attached to your skin that you could learn to "read" intuitively. The problems are dermatalogical sensitivity from the adhesive and the inability to wear it 24/7 to make the erading really feel like a new sense. But who knows?
glenstein 4 hours ago
Seeing the earth's magnetic field is amazing, but it's just as built in as a mantis shrimp's ability to see a wider color spectrum. Incredible, but not in and of itself a mark of intelligence.
whatever1 6 hours ago
RachelF 4 hours ago
Watch a bird come in fast and then land on a narrow twig.
Bird neurons are roughly half the length of mammal neurons. This means you can pack in around 8x more neurons in a given volume.
gojiberries 4 hours ago
loeg 2 hours ago
whatever1 2 hours ago
jyounker an hour ago
Most birds don't spend their time flying at high altitudes. Most of the time they're remarkably close to the ground, and there are lots of obstacles when you're close to he ground. Some of those are trying to avoid being eaten, and others are looking for dinner.
> Humans routinely travel at 40mph+ too (bicycles, motorcycles, cars) and have to contend with much more diverse and surprising conditions on the ground.
That's just within the last 150 years, and has no relevance for our evolutionary history.
doodlebugging 7 minutes ago
Watching drone racing videos gives an idea of just how complicated the task turns out to be - flitting through narrow openings at speed and zipping around obstacles that suddenly appear. Birds were doing this millenia before anyone programmed a drone.
xyos 4 hours ago
silverFork 3 hours ago
They had complete trust in my family and not others. So they could tell the difference.
Intelligence is not about some IQ test.
NorwegianDude 4 hours ago
Humans can make decisions and an action in less than 125 ms for very fast people.
jyounker an hour ago
Joakal an hour ago
Kinrany 3 hours ago
Glyptodon 2 hours ago
chaostheory 43 minutes ago
inglor_cz 5 hours ago
Hens/chickens are usually synonymous with "not very bright". Crows and ravens are usually depicted as smart and cunning.
alpineman 5 hours ago
AnthonBerg 4 hours ago
Went to find something to read on the matter. This paper is fun!: https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10071-016-1064-4
brnt 3 hours ago
vibebingo 3 hours ago
randomNumber7 36 minutes ago
InsidiousWombat 2 hours ago
The "journalist" just really wanted to make article out of "smol brain processes faster"
wordsunite 2 hours ago
amelius 5 hours ago
dlcarrier 5 hours ago
newobj 5 hours ago
chiasabah 3 hours ago
functionmouse 5 hours ago
dools 4 hours ago
tty456 3 hours ago
bitwize 6 hours ago
I don't share this belief, but the more we find out about avian intelligence, the less surprised we should be that people actually think this.
SoftTalker 6 hours ago
misnome 5 hours ago
fsiefken 5 hours ago
Extreme miniaturization eliminates travel distance, giving near-zero latency and high metabolic efficiency despite 1/5th the neurons of a chimp.
leftbit 5 hours ago
https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/bird-brains-have-...
doodlebugging 4 hours ago
Seems that some posters would rather shoot the messenger that delivers information that they don't agree with.
From interacting with domestic and wild animals for most of my life I figured out a long time ago that they understand their own world and their place in it way better than many of us understand the world we have created for ourselves.
conartist6 2 hours ago
I wonder if this could also have something to do with it. The bird would presumably be sharper at spotting the pattern partly because our eyes are trying to pick it out from in the midst of other kinds of "floater" patterns that we're (very) used to filtering out