Analyzing Frontier Model Progress with My Favourite Game: Prince of Persia (blog.priyan.in)

48 pointsby msephtona day ago31 comments

jablongo 4 minutes ago

This isn't really comparing the models; he's using successive models to improve his rebuild of Prince of Persia. Either way though, it will be interesting to see which games, if any, resist implementation via LLM. I recently started a Starcraft 2 like real time strategy game with Fable managing many Opus agents and it got to a playable 3d in 3 days.

criemen 7 hours ago

A German magazine (c't) ran a Asteroids programming contest in 2008 - create a client with access to the emulator output of the game that provides keyboard inputs to control the game.

The highest scoring submission that won the contest had a high score of around 137k. Last week, I had GPT-6 Astra, Sol and Luna implement and hill-climb on this task, as I wanted to see how big the difference in smartness is. Luna implemented something, but never exceeded ca. 20k points, with a large variance. Sol got something in the area of the humans implementation.

Astra, which finished fastest, had a highscore of around 1.7Mm when the game seemed to fairly reliably crash. On the way, it disassembled parts of the ROM to extract information about the game.

I didn't do a ton work to document and measure the specifics, but it was very impressive.

looperhacks 6 hours ago

If I remember correctly, back then all "good" entries in the contest solved the game by syncing with the RNG and could basically predict where and how new asteroids would spawn. The difference between entries was planning ahead movement and residence against control issues due to the contest setup (like inputs getting delayed). I wonder how Astra managed so much better, I thought the problem was already solved

criemen 6 hours ago

Thanks! I went back, and had a look at both the contest rules and the highest scoring submission again. Turns out I benchmarked against infinite games, whereas the contest measured a 5min time limit. So, Astra solved a different problem.

Comparing strategies, though, Astra does something pretty different from the highest scoring submission. It doesn't predict the RNG, instead it reacts to the visuals on-screen, planning ahead by estimating velocity of all objects on screen. Unlike the winning solution, it actively flies the ship, whereas the winning solution basically only rotates and teleports. So Astra behaves more like a regular "perfect" player would, rather than one that breaks the PRNG.

suddenlybananas 4 hours ago

It is a bit frustrating that you reported it as being so much better than human made solutions despite not checking even the most basic conditions.

criemen 4 hours ago

My apologies, and it's too late to edit the parent now.

To be fair, though, I mainly ran this experiment to distinguish models, not to see if they were better than humans or not, so for that purpose it didn't really matter if the basic conditions were the same or not.

NitpickLawyer 5 hours ago

> On the way, it disassembled parts of the ROM

You should check the logs, there's probably a bunch of retro gaming forums that got hacked behind the scenes :D

Kuyawa 6 hours ago

I am going to try to build the original Prince of Persia using Swift as it is the best language for building a macOS game. Being a classic 2D cinematic platformer, Apple's native frameworks provide exactly what I need without the overhead of a massive cross-platform engine, and I love simplicity

So here goes my weekend, flag this and get a life

andsoitis 6 hours ago

Share it when you're done! Even if it isn't complete complete.

Kuyawa 2 hours ago

Already started and will be ready soon, check back in an hour

https://github.com/kuyawa/prince

tehlike 3 hours ago

Instead of fixing a broken version, maybe each model should have started from scratch

jablongo 3 minutes ago

yea for a real comparison between models this would have been better, but I have a feeling he just wanted to play the best possible version of PoP.

gambiting 39 minutes ago

The real miracle of AI is that it could work with these prompts at all

"now char coming but movement everything wrong ... prince is not in floor"

I'm a games developer and I have no idea what OP is asking for here.

smokel 7 hours ago

The prompts provided are atrocious. It's amazing that the LLMs actually built something useful.

> My first prompt was simple: "in this original code there 6502 assembly code for prince of persia, use the save level files and try to do it in c# console."

Do what in the what now in the console?

gcanyon 7 hours ago

"now char coming but movement everything wrong ... prince is not in floor"

I'm assuming a language barrier on the part of the author. I wonder if the models would do better being prompted in the author's main language.

cavemandaveman 6 hours ago

Or having another model proofread the prompts and write clearer instructions

koala_man 6 hours ago

Unsurprisingly it was buggy without the obligatory "Make no mistakes."

daemonologist 6 hours ago

Yeah, I'm thinking the nigh-unreadable AI-speak we get these days makes a lot more sense if this is what they're training on. Or maybe the author has translated the prompts from another language?

InsideOutSanta 6 hours ago

It's so confusing how the actual article is in English, but the prompts are just gibberish. But LLMs are pretty good at deciphering gibberish; I often put our CEO's absolutely atrocious E-Mails into ChatGPT and tell it to explain wtf he wants from me.

Also, I feel like the LLMs would have done better if they had started from scratch each time, rather than being burdened by the output from the previous attempt.

aksss 3 hours ago

The prompts were awful and really distracted from an otherwise cool project concept. Also, testing the next model by iterating on the first model’s crappy foundation. Why not start from the original each time?

rhipitr 7 hours ago

Off tangent but the latest prince of Persia game is really fun

pawelduda 6 hours ago

I played The Lost Crown and it's top tier, I assume you're talking about The Rogue?

Kuyawa 6 hours ago

The Lost Crown? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n4vaxKwZ5rQ

That looks really amazing

dofm 6 hours ago

It looks like one of those spam shooty game ads you get between Youtube Shorts.

Prince of Persia is a piece of contemplative, subtle, beautifully, artistically minimal motion puzzle art. God knows what that is.

dayvid 6 hours ago

It's one of the best recent metroidvanias. It deserves a lot more attention. I was surprised by how good it was.

7734128 5 hours ago

However, it's Ubisoft and therefore tainted.

hapless 5 hours ago

when the author mentioned playing prince of persia on a pc-xt, i assumed this was some kind of ai-generated nonsense

but no

they actually did port the game to the lowest-end hardware available in 1989. you could actually play prince of persia on an 8088 with a cga card!

brandonmenc 4 hours ago

Just about every PC game in 1989 ran on an XT with CGA.

hapless 2 hours ago

The XT came out in 1983, it was a real piece of shit by 1989 standards

Not to mention, the PC was a pretty, uh, "challenging" platform for video games. It amazes me someone managed to port something as graphically sophisticated as PoP to an 8088 with CGA.

dofm 6 hours ago

Just one thing you could do is not drag Prince of Persia into this.

Please.